ReviewEssays.com - Term Papers, Book Reports, Research Papers and College Essays
Search

Theory of Care Vs. Theory of Justice

Essay by   •  September 19, 2010  •  Essay  •  581 Words (3 Pages)  •  2,178 Views

Essay Preview: Theory of Care Vs. Theory of Justice

Report this essay
Page 1 of 3

Theory of Care Vs. Theory of Justice

Ethical philosophy has been defined on two separate halves over the years. One approach is that of a Theory of Justice, and one of a Theory of Care. These to theories share distinct differences in their explanations of moral reasoning. The Theory of Justice's masterminds, John Rawls and Bjorn Kant's set-in-stone beliefs of ethical Justice is the highest contradictory point of the two views. Annette Baier and Virginia Held's Theory of Care demonstrates a more highly caring and emotional platform on their views towards ethics.

Kant's theories came first in the early 1700's. His beliefs were based upon a fundamental idea known as "categorical imperative", which provides a basis for determining moral rules and prescribes that individuals should follow these rules. These views have the same implications as the Golden Rule of, "Do unto as you would have them do unto you".

For Rawls' moral philosophy, he used a technique similar to that of Kant's. In his 1971 classic A Theory of Justice, Rawls hoped to show us a view of a just state without having the implications of an unattainable utopian society. By having the people conceive themselves as possible constructors of a future just society and also having them ignore their own social, racial, and economic status, Rawls created a so-called Veil of Ignorance. Rawls then took away all information irrelevant to the question of justice. This created an environment known as Rawls' Original Position. From here, he deducted that a rational person would come up with two basic ideas of justice. One being to maintain personal liberties such as freedom of speech and freedom of religion. The other basic justice would be to have an equality to opportunity. In this equality, he envisioned the rich people of the society not overpowering the poorer; thus he allowed several inequalities to take place only on the grounds that it would benefit those people who are the poorest.

The ethics of care on the other hand backed the works of Annette Baier, Virginia Held, Carol Gilligan, and several other philosophers. This rationale defines not the role of fairness in a person's life, but care. This theory came from a feminist viewpoint of compassion, but has since been deemed equivocal to both genders. The ethics of care relies on communication, relationships,

...

...

Download as:   txt (3.4 Kb)   pdf (61.4 Kb)   docx (10 Kb)  
Continue for 2 more pages »
Only available on ReviewEssays.com