Police Discretion

Police Discretion

Police discretion is the ability to choose a course of action because of broad limits of power. It "refers to the autonomy an officer has in choosing an appropriate course of action" (The Police In America, 113). It "includes authority to decide which of the various means of helping the helpless, maintaining order, and keeping the peace are best suited to particular circumstances" (www.worldandi.com/specialreport/1989/january/Sa15878.htm). The police need to have discretion since it is impossible to record everything on what they are supposed to do and not do. We can also understand that if you could record all the rules and regulations it would be too extensive for an individual to comprehend.

Looking at the criminal justice system as a whole, I find that the police officers are the ones who exercise the most discretion. They maintain the ability to enforce the law at anytime and anywhere, in uniform and out of uniform. For example, they are the ones who make the decisions regarding who they will pull over and who they will arrest. They must make a discretionary decision on what to do about a crime in progress if, for instance, they are out of uniform shopping with their family. There can be quite a number of important decisions facing them everyday, especially if they are not in their uniforms.

It is crucial for the police to use discretion because there may be new situations which arise that they have not run across yet. For example, let us just say that a police officer pulls over an individual who was speeding. This person may explain to the officer that his reason for speeding was some kind of an emergency situation that maybe he/she never heard of before. The officer, using his/her discretion, possibly might not issue that individual a summons. On the other hand, if this officer were to pull over someone in a non-emergency situation, such as joyriding, he/she would most likely issue that person a summons.

To apply discretion correctly, there are certain attributes a police officer must possess. First, he/she must possess curiosity and rid of any blinders they used to attain (Policing in America, 249). They need to analyze each and every situation and circumstance that arises and question what people already apperceive.

Second, the police officer must bear the ability "to perceive danger" (249). Since an officer's safety is crucial in this world today, it is extremely important they possess this quality. We understand, though, that some officers may observe danger that is not even there and this could possibly result in "overreaction on their part" (250).

A third attribute that they must maintain is a tragic perspective. It is essential that they manifest empathy and compassion in certain situations (250). For example, imagine if you are driving a pregnant woman to the hospital. If a police officer pulled your vehicle over, would you not want this law enforcer to understand and empathize with what is happening here? There is a logical reason that you are speeding and you are hoping that he/she will understand that as well.

A fourth quality that police officers should dominate is "decisiveness" (250). It can be critical for an officer to resolve circumstances quickly at times. Fifth, it is important to have self-control to be reasonable and logical. Last, but not least, police officers should possess the quality of varied approaches, which can be considered as problem solving techniques (250). They must take into account certain situations "and solve them instead of treating them" (250).

There are three factors that influence an officer's use of discretion:

(1) offender variables, (2) situation variables, and

(3) system variables.

...