Hucklberry Finn

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn Essay

Chance Parks Period 2

Colonel Sherburn defines a true man to be one who is a leader, not a follower. While Ralph Waldo Emerson defines a man as only a non-conformist. While Colonel Sherburn may be right, Emerson has a valid point as well.

Emerson has a very good point in the way that, a man must be unique (a non-conformist) in order to be a "man". But then, what is this sought after title? Being a "man". Well, being man would be having masculinity, or having the guts to get up and do something that does not conform to the rest of society. Many would argue this point, but it is believed to be the correct one. A "man" is what he makes himself. Therefore, a man is a non-conformist.....To a degree.

Sherburn may very well speak the truth in his definition of a man, though not in my eyes. Sherburn's approach was a little rough around the edges. He says that one is only a man when he is a leader, and that most are not men. To be a "man", you must be a leader, once again, to a degree. The irony is, that when Sherburn makes this statement (A man is one who is a leader) he has a gun pointed at the people he is speaking with, intimidating them with it. Sherburn is a coward and a hypocrite. He hides behind the gun as a means of protecting himself from the mob. While it is true that, mob mentality is very weak and frail and easily broken by a show of violence, it was Sherburn who in fact, helped create the mob by shooting the old drunken man. He should have said that a man is one who has a big gun. Although Sherburn declares himself a man, he is not. Sherburn is simply a coward with a rifle.

Emerson has the better view, although Sherburn is right......to a very small extent. To be a non-conformist is often, to be a leader. When you do not conform to society, you lead yourself (Or others) a new way. Although a good reason as to why Sherburn is found lacking in his definition is because of the situation he was in when he made the statement. Emerson was an early hippy (As discussed in class); therefore he was full of new ideas. He happened to get one right, if you don't think out of the box, who will? If you don't nothing new will happen. That is why you have to get up and do it yourself. If not to better the world, but just to see if you can, and if you can't,