Compare Two Poems by Wilfed Owen

Compare two poems by Wilfred Owen, showing how they reflected contemporary attitudes to the 'Great War'. Refer closely to language and poetic techniques.

World War 1 broke out in 1914. At the beginning of the war, there was a great feeling of patriotism and enthusiasm. Young men were eager to join the armed forces, as they thought the glory and heroism of war would be enjoyable. Fighting in France was expected to be an exciting adventure. Thousands of men joined so they would have the honor of serving their Queen and country. Underage age boys lied about their age in order to join, which showed that the English people thought the war would be won and over quickly. Many patriotic poems and songs were written which encouraged the war effort even more. However, by 1917 the true horror and cruelty of fighting in the war was unveiled. The soldiers experienced true pain, hardship and psychological damage. For those who were left in England, there was huge grief for the loss of life, and people's attitudes to the war changed dramatically.

Wilfred Owen was a teacher who fought from the begging of the 'Great War'. Owen himself displayed a contrasting attitude as the war progressed through his poems. Before he signed up, he shared the view of the British public, and wrote 'Ballad of Peace and war' in 1914. He thought that peace was good but it was better to fight for the country. By 1917, his poetry had changed from blind patriotic disillusion and encouragement, to bitterness and anger. "Dulce et Decorum Est', and "Disabled" were poems he wrote during his time in Craig Lockheart hospital, where he was suffering from shell shock. He had seen the tragedy and graphic brutality of trench warfare, and the trauma he had seen and experienced had sunk in.

Both the poems focus on one main person or event. Wilfred Owen wrote these poems to highlight the reality of war, they were 'protest poems' to propaganda declaring fighting for soldiers as an honor.

'Disabled' focuses on a dingle victim of war, now disabled and in a wheelchair, spending his life in an institute, lonely and unloved. The emphasis of the poem is the tragic consequences of war, and the man's pain and suffering evokes great empathy for the disabled man in the reader. Losing his legs in the war has robbed him of his masculinity and youth forever. The message of this poem is that the man wasted his life and that he joined for the wrong reasons 'He thought he'd better join. He wonders why.'

'Dulce et Decorum est' focuses on one specific incident, a soldier who dies during a gas attack. The reader is shown the reality of war, and the poem is directed at the reader 'If you could hear, at every jolt, the blood'. This technique immediately involves the reader and grabs attention. The reader imagines how bad the reality of trench warfare really was, and if they experienced it then their attitude would have changed. This kind of death is not 'sweet' or 'fitting' is the message throughout the poem

The feelings of bitterness and anger are strongly shown in both of the poems. Displayed in 'Dulce et Decorum Est', is Owens annoyance of writers such as Jessie Pope who wrote 'Who's for the Game?', a patriotic war poem, which showed the naivete and innocence of the people back home who thought war was a game. 'The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est

Pro patria mori', demonstrates what was said and thought at the begging of the war was wrong, and the word 'lie' is used to show that Owen no longer believed the statement as he once had, and that it was no longer believed by people because their attitudes had changed. The Latin expression shows encouragement to fight, and displays soldiers as heroic and glorious, which clearly angers Owen. In 'Disabled', their are examples the people who had signed up feeling excited, glamorous and expecting glory 'And care of arms; and leave; and pay arrears.' The repetition of the word 'and' shows the abundance of good things the war represented at the beginning. Now footballers were seen as more heroic 'Some cheered him home, but not as crowds cheer Goal.' This empathizes that the enthusiasm for the war was lost and that the people no longer cheered for war veterans. The use of the word 'Some', shows only a few people notices him which creates a sense of sympathy in the reader. The difference in attitudes of British people who stayed at home is emphasized by directly following the phrase 'drums and cheers', with 'not as crowds cheer Goals.'

Attitudes of the soldiers changed dramatically as they experienced emotional damage and suffering in the trenches. They saw the horrific reality of death and realized what they were told before they joined was all lies and that war was not fun or exciting. Dulce et Decorum Est shows this with the line 'In all my dreams, before my helpless sight,

He plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning'. The soldiers experienced nightmares and were traumatized by the scenes of death they witnessed. Owen uses a graphic image of a dying man, which is emphasized by the ending verbs, which are the climax to the stanza. The word 'guttering' is an ugly sound and imitates the noise in the dying mans throat. The imagery is very graphic and shows that Owen experienced disturbing events during his time in the war, and he was no longer disillusioned by thinking that it was would a glamorous to die for the country.

'Disabled' also shows a change of attitude in a soldier, 'Tonight he noticed how the women's eyes

Passed from him to the strong men that were whole', displays how the soldiers life was permanently affected by the 'Great War', as he feels that he can no longer have relationships with women. He has lost his confidence, and he is bitter that he has been stripped of his self-respect because of the loss of his legs. For the man, fighting in the war did not 'please his Meg', and he thinks that because he was so naive he wasted

...