- Term Papers, Book Reports, Research Papers and College Essays

Compare & Contrast the Rocking Horse Winner and the Destructors

Essay by   •  April 1, 2011  •  Essay  •  1,342 Words (6 Pages)  •  2,712 Views

Essay Preview: Compare & Contrast the Rocking Horse Winner and the Destructors

Report this essay
Page 1 of 6

Compare & Contrast The Rocking Horse Winner and The Destructors

In D.H. Lawerence's short story, "The Rocking Horse Winner", and Grahm Greene's "The Destructors, there are many truths to consider. Although these two stories are considerably different, the message is the same. Whether in a real life-like story "The Destructors" or a fantacy like "The Rocking Horse Winner", the seeds of materialism are seen culuminating in lives of its characters. The aspects of materialism in these two stories develop desired conclusions by its characters. In order to understand the similar message of Greene short story "The Destructors" and Lawerences "The Rocking Horse Winner", one must scrutinize the various aspects of each story.

When comparing the themes of each story, surprising similarities arise. First, both are developed around the lives of children. In "The Destructors" a group of boys called all of the boys in the Wormsley Gang have the save view of the world around them. They have grown up together and share stories about the bombs that destroyed their town. They also challenge each other to accomplish various tasks. The house that the boys ultimately destroy represents the greediness of Mr. Thomas, an architect who owns the tattered home. The Wormsley Gang called him 'Old Misery'. In the Rocking Horse Winner", the story's plot is thickend by a a young boys obsessive desire to "become lucky". This young boy, Paul, believes that his house is continually whispering, "...there must be more money...there must be more money". Paul is able to relate the self-proclaimed dissatificatoin of his mothers life with the odd mood of his house. Paul knows that although his mother appears to have everything together on the outside, she does not love him on the inside. Paul believes that he can please his mother if he is able to find a way to give her more money. In both stories, the houses were very symbolic.

When comparing the emotions and feelings of "The Destuctors" and "The Rocking Horse Winner", one will discover how their characteristics affect the plot. In "The Destructors", Trevor, who is the more natural leader of the Wormsley Gang, discovers his own anger upon visiting the home of Mr. Thomas. Trevor then fuels the already burning curiosities of the gang, by challenging them to do something about it. In "The Rocking Horse Winner", Paul's mother is also angry. She feels the life she desperately desires, is not being supported with her husbands income. She equates luck with on-going wealth. She told Paul that she was lucky before she got married. She blames the despair of her life, home, marriage, and social status solely on her husband.

In "The Rocking Horse Story", Paul loves his mother dearly. Despite her obvious selfishness and denial, Paul literally dedicates his life to fulfilling her greedy expectations. Lawernce depicts this love first of all by the innocent questions Paul feels he can ask his mother. Secondly, Paul's concern throughout the story was to make more money for his mother by finding a way to become lucky. Pauls mother equated wealth with luck and nothing else. At no point did Paul pursue the same ambitions of his mother. He was always more interested in 'quieting the voices' of his house. Throughout "The Rocking Horse Winner", Paul's behavior defined the love for his mother.

In "The Destructors", everyone portrayed their own greedy agendas. The boys portray their greed, although not physically materialistic, by destroying an old mans home. Their greed was caused by materialism, much like Paul's in "The Rocking Horse Winner". The selfish behavior of the boys in the Wormsley Gang was due to the materialistic values of 'Old Misery'. Mr. Thomas carried his share of greediness as well. Although he was a professional architect, with many resources and money to take care of his home........he didn't. Greene gives evidence of Mr. Thomas' materialisitic values by showing him stuffing a mattress full of money instead of fixing his toilet.

The setting of each story is vital to their themes. Both stories use the homes to symbolize the demise of the plot. Lawerence concludes "The Rocking Horse Winner", with Pauls mother finding him, in his room, desperately riding his rocking horse at 1:00 in the morning. This physical and psychotic drive of Paul to find a winner, by riding his toy horse causes him to die in his own home. Greene concludes "The Destructors", with Mr. Thomas' home being completely destroyed when his driver pulls



Download as:   txt (7.5 Kb)   pdf (100.4 Kb)   docx (11.5 Kb)  
Continue for 5 more pages »
Only available on