ReviewEssays.com - Term Papers, Book Reports, Research Papers and College Essays
Search

F.Scott Fitzgerald's "the Great Gatsby" Comparison and Contrasted with Jane Austens Pride and Prejudice

Essay by   •  February 16, 2011  •  Research Paper  •  1,707 Words (7 Pages)  •  2,481 Views

Essay Preview: F.Scott Fitzgerald's "the Great Gatsby" Comparison and Contrasted with Jane Austens Pride and Prejudice

Report this essay
Page 1 of 7

The reading of other texts contributes to creating meaning for other texts. An example of this is Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, this novel is more easily understood when it is compared and contrasted to other literature works, such as F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. The aspects of the two novels that can be compared and contrasted are the plot development, characterisation, setting, narrative point of view, writer's context and themes and issues.

The plot of Pride and Prejudice is about a lower upper class woman in the 18th century who is trying to get all of her daughters married to wealthy men. Jane, Mrs Bennet's oldest daughter falls in love with the handsome and wealthy Bingley. But Bingley's sister and best friend Darcy try to pull them apart. Darcy is a very proud and arrogant character, who Elizabeth hates because of his involvement in her sisters heartbreak. Darcy falls in love with Elizabeth and she then ends up falling in love Darcy, which results in them both getting married as well as Jane and Bingley.

The plot of The Great Gatsby is about a young man, Nick Carraway who moves to New York where the occupants are obsessed with wealth and status in the Jazz age of the 1920's. Nick meets Jay Gatsby, a wealthy man who is trying to win back his love Daisy. She is now unfortunately married to wealthy and arrogant Tom Buchanan. Gatsby reunites with Daisy but shortly after he is murdered by Tom's mistress's husband, who mistakes him as his late wife's killer. After Gatsby is killed Tom and Daisy flee, and Nick is left to pick up all of the pieces.

The similarities between the plot developments of the two novels are that the protagonists are both looking for love, in a society that is ruled by wealth and status. The differences are that The Great Gatsby has a bittersweet ending and in Pride and Prejudice all of the conflicts are resolved and everyone ends up been happy. This is because Pride and Prejudice is a satirical piece of work and The Great Gatsby is more a dramatic novel .In The Great Gatsby the reader is able to learn how emotions can disillusion people and this idea of understanding also flows in Pride and Prejudice and is one of the main conflicts in the plot. The characters also contribute to the plot through their characterisation.

In Pride and Prejudice the dramatic method of characterisation is used. Austen has used the 'show me don't tell me' approach to her work. Characters are revealed through their dialogue, actions and responses. For Example Darcy's character is revealed through comments that other people make "He is a most disagreeable, horrid man, not at all worth pleasing. So high and so conceited, that there was no enduring him...I quite detest the man". Only the main characters such as Darcy and Elizabeth are complex and are able to develop and change their own opinions and views. All of the other characters do not develop or change throughout the novel and they are stereotyped to fit the roles that they are given. In comparison the characters in The Great Gatsby are also simple flat characters. The only complex character is Nick who is able to make his own judgement about morals and voice his own opinions. For example this is how nick describes Tom when he first meets him 'two shining arrogant eyes had established dominance over his face and gave him the appearance of always leaning aggressively forward.' The contrast between the protagonist's and lesser characters emphasises the themes and issues that both writers are trying to portray. By understanding how F. Scott Fitzgerald uses this unique contrasting, the reader is able to readily identify how Jane Austen used the same device. F. Scott Fitzgerald makes use of the discursive method of characterisation in The Great Gatsby, which contrasts Austen's method of characterization. Nick describes the characters and he makes many comments about their personalities and actions. The setting that the characters live in also reveals and develops them further.

Pride and Prejudice is set in the late 18th century during the Napoleonic wars (1797-1815). The times affect how the characters act and how they respond to certain situations because of the traditions and manners that were expected from them. The novel is set in rural England in an upper class society.The setting only shows how the upper class people live and never looks at any of the other aspects of that time. In contrast The Great Gatsby is very symbolic with its settings. The novel is set in the Jazz age of the 1920's in New York. Each of the classes within New York, live in a distinct setting to symbolise their status within society. For example Tom and Daisy live in East Egg which symbolises traditional inherited wealth. Their house is described to be a very elaborate "Georgian Colonial Mansion" with a very expensive "sunken Italian garden, half an acre of deep, pungent roses and a snub nosed motor boat that bumped the tide off shore". West Egg represents the upper / middle class people, who have a wealth that is created and not inherited. The Valley of the Ashes symbolises the lower working class people, which is where Myrtle and George live. Their surroundings are described to be a solum dumping ground" the "interior was unprosperous and bare; the only car visible was the dust covered wreck of a ford". The setting is reaved as the narrator describes it, either from a first person point of view or a third person point of view.

The narrative point of view in Pride and Prejudice is an omniscient third person point of view, the events are told by a narrator but through Elizabeth's eyes. The narrator endorses Elizabeth's points of view making the reader be on her side but is also describes how the other characters are feeling as well. For example the narrator expresses how Elizabeth feels. 'Elizabeth was much too embarrassed to say a word.'

In contrast The Great

...

...

Download as:   txt (9.6 Kb)   pdf (120.2 Kb)   docx (12.3 Kb)  
Continue for 6 more pages »
Only available on ReviewEssays.com
Citation Generator

(2011, 02). F.Scott Fitzgerald's "the Great Gatsby" Comparison and Contrasted with Jane Austens Pride and Prejudice. ReviewEssays.com. Retrieved 02, 2011, from https://www.reviewessays.com/essay/FScott-Fitzgerald's-the-Great-Gatsby-Comparison-and-Contrasted/39118.html

"F.Scott Fitzgerald's "the Great Gatsby" Comparison and Contrasted with Jane Austens Pride and Prejudice" ReviewEssays.com. 02 2011. 2011. 02 2011 <https://www.reviewessays.com/essay/FScott-Fitzgerald's-the-Great-Gatsby-Comparison-and-Contrasted/39118.html>.

"F.Scott Fitzgerald's "the Great Gatsby" Comparison and Contrasted with Jane Austens Pride and Prejudice." ReviewEssays.com. ReviewEssays.com, 02 2011. Web. 02 2011. <https://www.reviewessays.com/essay/FScott-Fitzgerald's-the-Great-Gatsby-Comparison-and-Contrasted/39118.html>.

"F.Scott Fitzgerald's "the Great Gatsby" Comparison and Contrasted with Jane Austens Pride and Prejudice." ReviewEssays.com. 02, 2011. Accessed 02, 2011. https://www.reviewessays.com/essay/FScott-Fitzgerald's-the-Great-Gatsby-Comparison-and-Contrasted/39118.html.